CRO or VP of Sales: Which Does Your Company Need?

By Steve LePatner

Founders and boards at AI and SaaS companies often ask me some version of the same question: should our next revenue leader be a Chief Revenue Officer or a VP of Sales? Plenty of companies hire one when they actually need the other. The result is a leader who is either underused or in over their head.

I have been recruiting sales and go-to-market leaders since 1997 and founded Howard Lee & Associates in 2002. The clearest way I know to answer this question is to stop thinking about the title and start with what the role must own over the next two to three years.

What a VP of Sales usually owns

A VP of Sales is responsible for the sales organization and the number it carries. In most software companies that means:

  • Building and leading the sales team, including hiring, coaching and managing out.
  • Owning the sales forecast and being accountable for new bookings.
  • Running the sales process, from qualification through close, and keeping pipeline reviews honest.
  • Working deals directly, especially the larger or more strategic ones.
  • Partnering with marketing and customer success without necessarily running those teams.

The best VPs of Sales are close to the field. They know which deals are real, which reps need help and where the process is breaking. That proximity is the point of the job.

What a CRO usually owns

A Chief Revenue Officer is responsible for revenue across the full customer lifecycle, not just new logo sales. The scope often includes:

  • Sales, customer success and account management under one leader, and sometimes marketing, partnerships and revenue operations as well.
  • Net revenue, meaning new business plus expansion, renewals and churn.
  • Go-to-market strategy, including segments, pricing input, channel decisions and territory design.
  • A seat at the executive table as a peer to the CEO, CFO and product leadership, with real input on company direction.
  • Leading leaders, since a CRO typically manages a VP of Sales, a head of customer success and others rather than individual reps.

A CRO spends more time on systems, structure and cross-functional alignment, and less time inside individual deals.

Signs you need a VP of Sales

In my experience, a VP of Sales is usually the right hire when:

  1. Your main problem is new bookings. You have product market fit signals, but the team is not closing consistently or predictably.
  2. The sales team is still small. If the leader would directly manage most of the sellers, you need someone who wants to coach and close, not someone who wants to manage managers.
  3. Customer success is working or has its own strong leader. If retention and expansion are in good hands, you may not need one person over all of revenue yet.
  4. The founder still owns go-to-market strategy. Many early stage founders want a strong operator to execute and scale the motion they have proven, not a new strategist.
  5. You need someone in the field quickly. A VP of Sales who has carried a team in a similar motion can make an impact without a long period of reorganization.

If this describes your company, our sales leadership recruiting page explains how we run these searches.

Signs you need a CRO

A CRO tends to be the better fit when:

  1. Revenue problems cross teams. Pipeline, conversion, onboarding and renewals are all part of the issue, and no single team leader can fix it alone.
  2. Expansion and retention matter as much as new logos. For many AI and SaaS products, a large share of growth comes from existing customers, and someone needs to own that whole picture.
  3. You already have managers who need a leader. If you have a sales leader, a customer success leader and a marketing leader who are not aligned, a CRO can bring them under one plan.
  4. The board wants one accountable revenue executive. At a certain stage, investors expect a single leader who can speak to the full revenue model.
  5. The CEO needs to step back from go-to-market. A CRO can take ownership of strategy so the founder can focus on product, fundraising or other priorities.

Common mistakes I see

A few patterns show up again and again:

  • Hiring a CRO title for a VP of Sales job. Companies sometimes offer the bigger title to win a candidate. If the role is really about closing new deals with a small team, a true CRO will get frustrated and a VP who took the title may struggle when the scope grows.
  • Hiring a VP of Sales and expecting CRO results. If churn, onboarding and marketing are part of the problem, a VP of Sales without authority over those teams cannot fix them.
  • Skipping the role definition work. Before outreach starts, the CEO and the board should agree on what the leader owns, who reports to them and how success is measured in the first year.

How to decide

Start by writing down the three biggest revenue problems you need solved in the next 18 months. Then ask which of them sit inside the sales team and which cross teams. If most are sales problems, you likely need a VP of Sales. If most cross sales, customer success and marketing, you likely need a CRO.

It also helps to look at who else is on the team. A CRO without strong managers underneath will end up doing the VP of Sales job anyway. A VP of Sales hired into a company that really needs a CRO will be measured against a scope they were never given.

If you are building a revenue team for an AI product specifically, our AI company recruiting page covers what we look for in leaders who sell technical products.

FAQ

Can a VP of Sales grow into a CRO?
Yes, and many do. It works best when the company is clear about the path, the leader has shown they can manage managers and partner across teams, and the scope grows in stages rather than all at once.

Should a CRO report to the CEO?
In most companies a CRO reports directly to the CEO. If the role would report to someone else, it is usually a sign that the job is closer to a VP of Sales scope.

Do early stage companies ever need a CRO?
Sometimes, especially when the company already has meaningful recurring revenue and separate sales and customer success teams. For most very early companies, a strong sales leader who can build the first team is a better first hire.

Is it a problem to have both a CRO and a VP of Sales?
No. In larger organizations it is common for a VP of Sales to report to a CRO. The key is that each role has a clear, separate scope.

Related reading: When to Hire Your First VP of Sales After Series A | Retained vs Contingency Search for Sales Roles

Talk it through

If you are deciding between a CRO and a VP of Sales, I am happy to talk through your situation. You can book a 15 minute call with me, and you can learn more about the firm on our services page.

Hiring for a sales or technical role?

Book a 15 minute call with Steve to talk through your search.

Book a 15 Minute Call